Recommendations for accepting peer-review

　When I was an editorial committee member of Ohyo Butsuri, I proposed an article to Professor Emeritus Tadashi Shibata of the University of Tokyo entitled "Be proactive in peer-reviewing papers!". It is a wonderful article that carefully explains to young researchers with little experience in peer reviewing what kind of mindset they should have when doing it. Therefore, I highly recommend that you read it.

　Even if the field of a peer-review paper is slightly outside your own, you may still be willing to peer-review it if you are motivated to study that field. Peer review is not a criticism of the content, but rather a timely submission of comments that are scientifically sound and encourage constructive discussion.

My awards about peer-review process

Reviewer Excellence 2024 Award for Physical Review Materials from American Physical Society (2024). Certificate
Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2023 for Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter from IOP publishing (2024).  Certificate
Outstanding Referees of the Physical Review journals (2024).　　Certificate
Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2021 for Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics from IOP publishing (2022). 　　Certificate
Outstanding Reviewer Awards 2020 for Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter from IOP publishing (2021). 　　Certificate
IOP trusted reviewer from IOP publishing (2020).　　Certificate

Back to Home